Be afraid of Big Marijuana
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
- David Frum: In August, the Obama administration retreated on marijuana policy
- Frum: It's important to appreciate that "medical marijuana" is a laughable fiction
- He says the emerging marijuana industry will target young people and minorities
- Frum: It is a myth that marijuana is harmless and nonaddictive; we need better policy
Editor's note: David
Frum, a CNN contributor, is a contributing editor at The Daily Beast. He
is the author of eight books, including a new novel, "Patriots," and a
postelection e-book, "Why Romney Lost." Frum was a special assistant to
President George W. Bush from 2001 to 2002.
(CNN) -- "We're on the brink of creating Big
Marijuana." That warning comes from my friend Kevin Sabet, a former
senior adviser on drug control policy under President Barack Obama.
Sabet now heads Smart Approaches to Marijuana, an anti-legalization group on whose board I sit.
At the end of August, the
administration that Sabet served announced a retreat on marijuana
policy. It will allow the states of Washington and Colorado to proceed
with the legal retailing of marijuana. And it will get out of the way of
the approximately 20 states that allow so-called medical marijuana.
With a referendum on
marijuana scheduled in 2014 in Alaska and action likely in coming years
in California, Maine, Massachusetts, Nevada and Oregon, half the states
in the union may soon allow the sale of marijuana to almost anybody
determined to buy it.
To understand where the
marijuana debate is going, it's important to appreciate that "medical
marijuana" is a laughable fiction. In California, the typical user of so-called medical marijuana is a 32-year-old white man with no life-threatening illness but a long record of substance abuse.
Under Colorado's
now-superseded medical marijuana regime, only 2% of those prescribed
marijuana suffered from cancer, and only 1% from HIV/AIDS. Some 94%
cited unspecified "pain" as the justification for their pot
prescription. False patients find unscrupulous doctors: in Oregon, only
10 practitioners write the majority of all marijuana prescriptions in
the state. When a TV crew visited a marijuana dispensary in Los Angeles
last year, they met for five minutes with a man who turned out to be
licensed as an acupuncturist and were then handed a prescription signed
by a doctor they never met.
Where marijuana is
allowed to be sold, somebody will sell it. As Sabet warns, the marijuana
industry of the future is already taking form. In March of this year,
Fortune magazine devoted its prestigious cover to the Arcview Group, an investor group seeking to capitalize on the emerging marijuana market.
Warren Buffett famously
explained the economics of tobacco: "It costs a penny to make. Sell it
for a dollar. Plus, it's addictive!" Alcohol conforms to the same ugly
logic. Half of all the alcohol consumed in the United States is consumed by underage and excessive drinkers.
As one industry observer has bitterly remarked: "Regardless of its
public stance, the industry considers underage and excessive drinking to
be profit centers that need nurturing, rather than problems that need
solving."
Sabet foresees that the
emerging marijuana industry will target the same populations as are
targeted by the tobacco and alcohol industries -- young people and
racial minorities -- and for the same reason: secure and contented
people don't tend to be heavy consumers of psychoactive substances.
Sabet has laid out a better vision of an effective national drug control policy in his new book, "Reefer Sanity."
Sabet's message eschews punishment in favor of treatment; it replaces
condemnation with compassion. But it understands the difference between
compassion and credulity. Nobody ever helped a troubled person by
accepting lies at face value.
"Reefer Sanity" debunks
seven myths about marijuana, beginning with the biggest myth of all:
that this drug is harmless and nonaddictive. It's a message that is all
the more timely in the face of last week's report by the Department of
Health and Human Services that regular marijuana use surged over the half-decade from 2007 to 2012.
"Reefer Sanity" is the
best explication I've seen of the errors on which the case for marijuana
legalization has been built. It's a book that every concerned parent
should read -- and that every advocate of legalization should be
challenged to answer.